DIY Series – Part 23: What to Keep Physical and What to Digitize — Building Your Own Hybrid System

You don’t have to choose sides. When it comes to organizing your life, you can live in both worlds—physical and digital—without feeling like you’re falling behind or clinging too tightly. The key is to build a system that works for how you live, think, and access information. This post will help you decide what deserves to stay in your hands and what belongs in the cloud.

Start with Purpose, Not Pressure

Before scanning or discarding anything, ask yourself: Why do I need this? Is it for memory, legal reasons, reference, peace of mind, or daily use? Let your personal goals shape your decisions—not trends, not tech marketing, and not outside opinions.

What to Keep Physical (and Why)

Some items are simply better to hold on to. Originals of legal documents like birth certificates, wills, and titles should always be stored safely, even if you’ve scanned them. Sentimental items such as handwritten letters, children’s drawings, and personal journals often carry emotional weight that digital copies can’t replace. Textured artwork or crafts, family heirlooms, and physical books you regularly read or enjoy seeing in your space also fall into this category. You don’t have to digitize everything just because you can. Physical items that serve a purpose or bring joy have a valid place in your system.

What to Digitize (and Why)

Digitizing gives you access, security, and peace of mind. It’s especially useful for items that fade over time, get lost easily, or are needed on the go. Start with receipts, bills, and paperwork you reference occasionally but don’t need to physically file. Medical records, especially when managing long-term care, are easier to share and track when stored digitally. Old photos are great to preserve, back up, and organize once they’re scanned. Manuals and reference docs often already exist online, so scan or recycle if needed. Academic or professional materials like notes or research can stay digital unless you need to annotate by hand. If you want to search it, share it, or copy it—digitize it.

What Works in Both Formats

Some things benefit from being both physical and digital. A favorite family recipe can live in your kitchen and your cloud folder. Tax records are best stored with a physical copy and a digital backup. Artwork can be displayed and also preserved in a portfolio. Your child’s school projects or art can be kept selectively in paper form and scanned for digital albums or future use. This isn’t indecision—it’s flexibility. You’re designing a system for real life.

How to Structure Your Hybrid System

Start by setting clear zones for both types of content. Use a labeled drawer, file box, or folder for physical items, and mirrored categories in your digital storage. Apply consistent naming across both: if a folder is called “Health Records” on your computer, use the same label for the paper version. Back up both types—use a waterproof container or fire-safe for key documents, and always have a cloud and external drive backup for digital files. Review your system a few times a year. Ask yourself: Did I reach for the paper or the digital version more often? Let real use guide your updates.

You Don’t Have to Rush

There’s no prize for scanning everything overnight, and there’s no shame in keeping a drawer full of cards and letters. Some things are meant to be held. Others are better searchable, protected, and easy to share. The goal is not to go paperless—it’s to be intentional. Your hybrid system doesn’t need to look like anyone else’s. Build it one decision at a time, at your own pace.


This post is part of the Digital Organization Series, where I walk you through everything you need to know about scanning, organizing, and managing your digital files. Whether you’re just starting or looking to refine your system, you can explore the full series here: DIY Series.